Above the Law
How has executive power been shaped by rule of law in America?
In this lesson, students examine how the rule of law and the principle of limited government shape and constrain executive power in the United States. Through analysis of the Declaration of Independence, constitutional principles, and landmark Supreme Court cases, students investigate how presidential authority has been expanded, challenged, and restricted throughout American history. Students apply their understanding through legal reasoning, collaborative discussion, and a moot court activity focused on contemporary questions about executive power and constitutional limits
Objectives:
- Students will be able to define the rule of law, limited government, executive privilege, separation of powers, and protection of minority rights
- Students will be able to identify references to the rule of law in the Declaration of Independence
- Students will identify specific Constitutional powers of the president
- Students will learn and teach their peers a Supreme Court case relating to executive power and the rule of law
- Students will evaluate historically when executive powers been restricted and when they have been supported through Supreme Court rulings
- Students will read a current Supreme Court case focused on executive power and participate in a mini-moot court activity as lawyers and judges debating both sides of the case
Assessment:
- Student reflection on decisions and legal patterns relating to Limited Government Jigsaw
- Students will choose to either write a proposed constitutional amendment outlining limits on executive power or will write a ruling for the Trump v. Slaughter court case
Resources
Download Lesson
DownloadFeatured Lesson Plans
Colonial Grievances and the Social Contract
In this lesson, students examine how the grievances in the Declaration of Independence demonstrate a broken social contract. Through a matching activity and analysis of draft documents from the Library of Congress, students identify patterns of unfairness and evolving argumentation. Using a Claim-Evidence-Reasoning framework, they practice identifying them as legal arguments and apply their understanding to modern contexts before completing a final written evaluation.
Protecting Rights
Students will analyze how government power has been defined and limited over time through Influences on the Founding, various Founding Documents, and landmark Supreme Court cases.
A Living Constitution
In this lesson, students investigate how the Constitution balances stability and change through the amendment process and civic participation. Through analysis of Article V, historical amendments, and case studies of social movements, students examine how citizens have influenced constitutional change over time. Students evaluate why the amendment process is intentionally difficult, explore how civic action can lead to reform, and consider the role of individuals and groups in shaping a living Constitution.